Freight Quote Comparison Worksheet
Once quotes are in hand, the useful question is not which number is lowest — it is whether the numbers describe the same job. This worksheet compares offers you have already received, line by line, so differences in scope surface before they become differences at the dock.
Published · SENA Logistics
What this worksheet is for
Step 1: Freeze one shipment version
A quote only means something against a fixed description of the freight. Before comparing anything, settle a single version and use it for every request. If a detail changes, start a new version rather than mixing inputs across quotes.
- Packaged dimensions and gross weight per unit, and how many units
- Commodity description, and freight class where applicable
- Origin and destination, including ZIP codes
- Access at both ends: dock, liftgate, or other
- Requested dates and time windows
Freight class, where it applies, is not a formality: carriers describe class as reflecting how easily a shipment can be handled, transported, and protected, and it is derived from density and related handling factors. Quoting the same freight under two different class assumptions produces two different offers for what looks like the same shipment.
Step 2: Normalize the scope
Two quotes can carry the same headline rate and still cover different work. Normalize each component separately, and write down whether it is included, excluded, or unclear.
- Equipment or service being quoted — and whether it matches what you asked for
- Dock or liftgate at pickup and at delivery, stated for each end
- Ground-level unloading versus inside delivery, and how far inside
- Appointment or notification requirements, and who arranges them
- Limited-access conditions at either location
- Pickup and delivery windows
- Transit estimate versus a guaranteed commitment — these are not the same thing
The transit point deserves care. A quoted transit time is usually an estimate, and an estimate is not a guarantee unless the quote says so specifically. Treating an estimate as a commitment is an avoidable misunderstanding.
Step 3: Separate included and excluded charges
Line up base rate, fuel, and accessorial charges side by side, and record each quote's validity period. Published carrier guidance notes that shipment characteristics, service level, added delivery options and surcharges all affect the charge — so a lower number may reflect different assumptions; confirm the scope before judging value.
Mark unknowns — never zero
If a charge is not mentioned, record it as "not stated," not as $0. An unmentioned surcharge is not an absent surcharge; it is an unanswered question. This keeps unanswered questions visible during comparison.
Step 4: Request revised written quotes if assumptions differ
If a quote appears to have been priced on assumptions that differ from your frozen shipment version — a dock that does not exist, a window you did not request, a class you did not state — ask for a revised quote in writing rather than adjusting the number mentally. Comparing a corrected quote against an uncorrected one is not a comparison.
Worked example: two quotes, different scope
Consider two hypothetical offers for the same shipment to a site without a dock. Quote A is quoted at ground level with liftgate at delivery. Quote B does not mention liftgate at delivery at all. They may look comparable on the page, and one may look cheaper.
They are not yet comparable. Quote B is silent on a service the delivery needs, so its scope is not yet confirmed. Until both quotes cover the same scope — or you have a written confirmation of what Quote B includes at delivery — no one can say which is cheaper. The honest summary is "not aligned yet."
No prices are shown here deliberately: comparisons that hinge on numbers belong to the actual quotes and the actual shipment.
Step 5: Reconcile before tendering
When quotes are aligned, confirm in writing that the booking matches what you compared: the same equipment, the same access, the same windows, and the same included services. If anything shifts at booking, note it. The comparison is only as good as the confirmation it ends with.
Blank comparison table
Print or copy this table and fill one column per quote. Where a detail is not stated, write “not stated” in that cell rather than leaving it blank or writing zero.
| Requirement | Quote A | Quote B | Confirmation needed |
|---|---|---|---|
| Origin ZIP and destination ZIP | |||
| Quote ID and date | |||
| Quote validity and expiry date | |||
| Packaged per-unit dimensions and gross weight · unit count | |||
| Commodity description · freight class, where applicable | |||
| Equipment or service quoted | |||
| Pickup access: dock, liftgate, or other | |||
| Delivery access: dock, liftgate, or other | |||
| Ground-level or inside delivery | |||
| Appointment or notification requirement | |||
| Pickup and delivery windows | |||
| Transit estimate or guaranteed commitment | |||
| Base rate | |||
| Fuel surcharge | |||
| Accessorial charges listed | |||
| Exclusions and open questions |
What this means for your next quote
SENA Logistics is a freight broker, not a motor carrier. We arrange transportation through carriers, and quoted charges depend on the shipment and the scope confirmed for it. Bring the frozen shipment details when you request a freight quote, and compare offers against this worksheet rather than against the headline number alone. For the services that commonly drive differences, see accessorial charges explained; for deliveries without a dock, see receiving freight without a loading dock.
Sources
- FedEx Freight — How LTL costs are calculated
One carrier's overview noting that density-based class, service level, added delivery options and surcharges affect the charge. Specific rules vary by carrier.
Related resources
Freight Quote Preparation Checklist
Ten details to gather before requesting a freight quote.
Common Freight Accessorial Charges Explained
What liftgate, inside delivery, and limited access cover — and what to confirm.
Receiving Freight Without a Loading Dock
Receiver-side planning for no-dock deliveries: equipment, dimensions, unloading area, and contacts.